Confused Young Man Has Sex With Girlfriend’s Twin Sister

“Brian" drove all day to get to his girlfriend’s house. Shortly after arriving, he got laid. Not naughty, you say? Well, consider that he mistakenly banged his girlfriend’s twin sister.

I met Kara in college. Three weeks after we first hooked up as study partners, we fucked. After that, we fucked on almost a daily basis for six months.

Then we both went home, I to Maryland and she to New York. We kept in touch the whole summer, bullshitting about our families and our jobs. Finally, at the end of July, neither of us could take it anymore and I decided to go visit her.

During the entire drive to Albany I thought about sex with Kara. I hadn’t had it in almost two months (or any sex, for that matter), and I felt like a kid on Christmas Eve. I bought condoms at every gas station I stopped at.

When I finally got to Kara’s house at five past two in the morning, she answered the door and seemed a bit confused by my presence. I attributed her reaction simply to my own fatigue. After traveling so much I assumed I was reading too much into things.

Not a single word was exchanged as I took her in my arms and kissed her. We made it to her couch and I went for her pants. She still
seemed a little hesitant, which I again brushed off as fatigue. After I started working my finger magic, though, she melted and we fucked. She didn’t seem herself while we did it, but it was still awesome. We both fell asleep on the couch.

Kara woke me up the next morning. I was still on the couch, completely naked with only a blanket covering me. I smiled up at her and told her how good the sex felt the previous night. She gave me a perplexed look, as if I’d just said, “Puppy blue noodle head.”

She asked me what the hell I was talking about, to which I replied with the same question. We started at each other for a few seconds, then her eyes widened with some grand realization. “What?” I asked, still absolutely baffled. Kara stood up straight, crossed her arms, and said, “That was Kristy, you dickhead.”

Kara had mentioned her sister Kristy in the past, but she never alluded to the fact that they were twins.